Wednesday, 7 May 2008

You just can't trust Sun headlines...

Well, actually, maybe that's not quite fair in this instance. This earlier post noted the story of Nick Cameron and Danielle Heaney, the latter of whom had said - as paraphrased in the words of a Sun headline - that 'I won't make love to bruv' after she and her half-brother, who had grown up separately from her, had been prosecuted for incest.

The story has now been picked up by ABC News in the United States, who filmed an interview with the couple in Scotland which can be watched on their website. (See also reports in the Scotsman and the Times). The reports suggest that they are living together, although it is unclear whether their relationship is sexual - the interview notes only that it would be unlawful for them to have a sexual relationship.

Interestingly, the ABC News report indicates that Heaney underwent a sterilisation operation after the birth of her first child (to a man from whom she is now divorced). Given that the two most common rationales for criminalising incest - first, that the children of incestuous unions are more likely to suffer from some kind of hereditary abnormality and second, that such relationships are frequently continuations of childhood abuse - would seem to have absolutely no application here, it does raise the question of whether criminalising (and prosecuting) relationships of this nature serves any purpose.

Tuesday, 6 May 2008

Peter Manuel: a further note

Further to the previous post on this blog, I have now obtained a copy of Wilson's book on Peter Manuel's trial. The following section is relevant:
'It is an appalling record for a man of thirty-one. But it is typical (except perhaps in degree) of the aggressive psychopath and there is little doubt that that is the appropriate label to hang on Manuel. It does not, however, explain matters. The causes of such a condition are as yet largely unknown and it is not yet possible to treat psychopaths, except the very young, with any real hope of success...
Before his trial, Manuel was examined by doctors, including eminent psychiatrists and neurologists, on behalf of the Crown and presumably found sane and fit to plead. The defence also had him examined, with a view to putting forward a special defence of insanity, but could not find support. They also considered putting forward a case of diminished responsibility, as explained to the jury by Lord Cameron, but were dissuaded from doing so by their client, who told them, with genuine laughter, that he "wanted nae mair o' that insanity business". It may be said that a plea of diminished responsibility, based on his being a psychopath, would not have availed him...'
(John Gray Wilson, The Trial of Peter Manuel: The Man Who Talked Too Much (1959) 230-231.)

Wednesday, 30 April 2008

Peter Manuel, 50 years on

An interesting report on the BBC News website today, based on claims by my former colleague Dr Richard Goldberg:

Vital information about Scotland's most notorious serial killer may have been suppressed to ensure he was hanged, a legal expert has claimed.

Peter Manuel was executed at Barlinnie prison in Glasgow in 1958 after being convicted of murdering seven people. Dr Richard Goldberg, of Aberdeen University's law school, believes evidence about Manuel's mental health was withheld from the court. He called on government archives on the case to be opened to the public…


(Click here for the full report)

The allegation of suppressing evidence is a serious one, even 50 years on. According to the BBC, Dr Goldberg has explained it as follows:

Dr Goldberg…said he believed Manuel may have escaped the gallows if the court had been told the full extent of his health problems, which included a form of epilepsy many believe can cause criminal behaviour.

He said: "I think there was considerable evidence that he was a psychopath, there was debate over whether there should be a reprieve, and in my view insufficient weight was given to that evidence and also to the fact that Manuel suffered from temporal lobe epilepsy.


At the time of Manuel’s trial, however, it was clear from the decision in Carraher v HM Advocate 1946 JC 108 that psychopathy was not a basis for a plea of diminished responsibility (which would ‘reduce’ murder to culpable homicide). It is rather more difficult to comment on the claim of temporal lobe epilepsy without further information, but there again the definition of diminished responsibility in use at the time (see HM Advocate v Savage 1923 JC 49) might have been thought to rule it out as a basis for the plea. Manuel, it seems, had been examined by medical experts both for the Crown and defence (although the position here is complicated by the fact that he chose to conduct his own defence at the trial). “Suppression” may be a possibility, but at first glance it seems more likely that medical evidence was not led simply because it was recognised that it could not affect the outcome of the trial. Whether it was taken into account in any discussions over whether Manuel should be reprieved from the death penalty is a separate question.

The BBC News report gives the impression that the trial proceedings were conducted in ignorance of Manuel’s mental health. That is not quite true: although no medical evidence was led, the trial judge (Lord Cameron) did discuss the issue in his charge to the jury. Indeed, it seems to have been widely recognised at the time that Manuel was a psychopath, and it was also recognised that this was no basis for a defence under Scots law: the issue was discussed in a 1959 book by John Gray Wilson (The Trial of Peter Manuel: The Man Who Talked Too Much). To say that “there was considerable evidence that [Manuel] was a psychopath” does not seem to be revealing anything new.

One final, rather mischievous, comment. Although many of the relevant records on Peter Manuel are not open to the public and are exempt from the provisions of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 – a request to see them could, in principle be made, but I have no idea whether it would succeed – the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission has considerable powers to obtain documents in the course of investigations, and the Commission can investigate alleged miscarriages of justice even where the person concerned is deceased. Whether the Commission would thank Dr Goldberg for suggesting that they take up Mr Manuel’s case is a question on which I express no view.

Update (30/04): The BBC News article has been fleshed out since I wrote this piece. It now indicates that Dr Goldberg has unsuccessfully requested the files, and quotes him as saying "The problem is that psychopathic personality disorder still is not a basis for a plea of diminished responsibility, unlike in England, and this remains an anomaly." That is true, but as noted above, it sits uneasily with the "suppression" thesis.

Tuesday, 29 April 2008

A Wednesday miscellanea

A round-up of a few recent developments, some more trivial than others. Thanks to Greg Gordon for details of one of the reports in (1).

(1) More inanimate objects

As this blog started with news of a man having sex with a bicycle, it seems only right to keep readers up to date with such practices, even belatedly. So click here for the Sun’s report of an unnamed Polish builder sacked for having sex with a hoover (apparently his “defence” that vacuuming one’s own underwear was “a common practice in Poland” failed), and here for the Telegraph’s report of an unnamed 32 year old Wiltshire man arrested for allegedly simulating sex with a lamppost.

(2) Anwar contempt hearing

On more important matters, the High Court hearing in respect of the contempt allegations against Aamer Anwar (see, most recently, this post) took place today. A report is available here on the BBC News website. It appears that the judges have made avizandum and will issue a decision in due course. Significantly, it appears that Liberty were granted permission to make submissions as ‘interveners’ (see this Scotsman report): such third-party intervention has not hitherto been a feature of Scottish criminal cases.

(3) Victim statements to be rolled out

The Scottish Government announced on Monday that the victim statement schemes – previously piloted in Ayr, Edinburgh and Kilmarnock – are to be rolled out across Scotland from April 1st 2009 (click here for the press release). It appears that the statements will be restricted to solemn procedure (not surprising given that the evaluation of the pilots found that take up was much lower in less serious cases) and that the statement will be made “after finding of guilt but before sentencing”. Quite what this means is unclear. Under the relevant statutory provisions (introduced by section 14 of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2003), victims (strictly, alleged victims) are to be afforded the opportunity to make a statement once a decision to prosecute has been taken, and not only after the accused is convicted – if this happens at all. There may be some sense in only taking statements after a “finding of guilt” (although it could lead to problems of delay in sentencing), but it would not be implementing the legislation as passed by Parliament.


Sunday, 27 April 2008

Jury consultation expected

A report on the BBC News website yesterday states that the Scottish Government plans to carry out a public consultation on the jury system this summer, and that the Justice Secretary has indicated that he is open to a substantial reduction in the size of Scottish criminal juries. (Thanks to Fiona Leverick for drawing this to my attention: see also reports in the Scotsman and the Herald.)

Apparently The Firm magazine – who interviewed Mr MacAskill – “is campaigning to reduce the size of a jury in Scotland from 15 members to 11”, having noted that jury remuneration costs £4 million per year.

There is no doubt that the size of the Scottish criminal jury is large by international standards. But the other unusual feature of Scottish juries is the simple majority verdict, which it would be difficult to justify retaining if its size were reduced (indeed, it is probably difficult to justify regardless of the size of the jury). We could, with a smaller jury, find ourselves requiring fewer votes in favour of conviction than any other jury system, at the same time as allowing significant dissent to be ignored. Mr MacAskill referred to juries of as few as seven members in some jurisdictions, but would it really be appropriate to convict someone of murder on the basis of convincing only four members of the public and over the objections of another three?

And if simple majority verdicts go, the cost savings are not so obvious, because it would then be necessary to entertain the possibility of retrials where juries fail to reach verdicts, with all the extra costs involved thereby. (Alternatively, we could just enter final verdicts of acquittal where juries fail to reach verdicts, but it is doubtful that such a proposal would command much support.)

The consultation is awaited with interest. And on the subject of juries, see this recently reported exchange from a voir dire during jury selection in Ashland, Wisconsin. It’s a small town, apparently:

[Court]: Any of you have relatives employed in a law enforcement related capacity? Ms. Eaton, do you have a relative employed in the law enforcement related capacity?

[Juror] Eaton: The judge.

[Court]: I like – I like to consider myself part of law enforcement or I may be disowned. You are related to me how?

[Juror] Eaton: Your mother.

Friday, 25 April 2008

The male stripper and the offensive weapon:
appeal dismissed.

Thanks to Scott Wortley and the anonymous commenter on the previous post for drawing my attention to this BBC News report indicating that the Crown's appeal in the Stuart Kennedy case has been dismissed. Apparently some confusion was caused because of a claim that Mr Kennedy's lawyers had not been notified of the hearing last week, but their absence has turned out to be neither here nor there as the court had decided to dismiss the appeal. A written opinion has not yet been issued.

The outcome is not all that surprising, particularly because in previous cases on the "reasonable excuse" question the court has approached the question as being one of whether the trial judge was entitled to take the view that the defence had been made out, rather than considering the point afresh. (See eg Hemming v Annan 1982 SCCR 432.) A case such as this seems to involve a factual judgment by the judge at first instance which an appeal court should be reluctant to interfere with. It may be, therefore, that the court has simply declined to interfere with Sheriff Stewart's decision, without going so far as to endorse Mr Kennedy's costume, but the written opinion should make this clear.

Friday, 18 April 2008

The male stripper and the offensive weapon:
latest developments

Readers of this blog may remember the acquittal of police stripogram Stuart Kennedy on charges of carrying offensive weapons – batons and a spray – as part of his act (see this earlier post). The Crown appeal against that acquittal was heard yesterday, and reports in the Daily Record and the Scotsman note what seems to be the core of the Crown argument. According to the advocate depute (Brian McConnachie QC), as quoted by the Daily Record:

"For the purposes of his act, he doesn't require a real police truncheon. He is in a public place and a place where he says trouble can arise.

If it was a reasonable excuse to be carrying a weapon because it forms part of your fancy dress – or fancy undress in this case – that could put people in possession of very dangerous weapons on the street.

You could have someone going to a party as a ninja warrior with nunchaku sticks or someone dressed as a ned carrying a knife and it was part of their fancy dress. The whole purpose of the law is to stop people carrying offensive weapons in public."


A written decision will be issued in due course.